Choosing the first or next fitness tracker often turns into a difficult dilemma, especially when the market is dominated by two leaders in the budget segment. Users constantly argue whether the time-tested Honor Band 5 or the new Xiaomi Mi Band 5. Both devices offer impressive functionality for a modest price, but the devil, as usual, lies in the details.
In this article, we will conduct an in-depth analysis of the technical characteristics, usability and real autonomy of these gadgets: you will learn which of the bracelets more accurately tracks sleep, which longer holds charge and whether to overpay for the novelty of the model from Xiaomi.
Before we jump to specific numbers, it’s important to understand the philosophy of each device.Honor relies on a classic rectangular shape and informative screen, while Xiaomi offers a more rounded design and magnetic charging.These differences define the entire experience of interacting with the gadget.
Body design and ergonomics
The look is the first thing a buyer notices.The Honor Band 5 has retained a recognizable elongated rectangular body that many find more austere and businesslike.The tracker's capsule is made of matte-coated plastic, making it resistant to small scratches in everyday wear.
On the other hand, the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has a more streamlined, oval shaped capsule. The glossy surface looks premium, but it is much more prone to scuffing. If you plan to wear a bracelet with a business suit or social events, this nuance can be crucial.
⚠️ Note: Xiaomi Mi Band 5 glossy plastic quickly loses its presentation when in contact with rigid watch straps or keys in your pocket.
The device sizes also vary.The Honor Band 5 has a larger screen, which has a positive effect on readability, but makes the bracelet more noticeable on the thin arm.The Xiaomi is compacter and lighter, barely felt during sleep, which is critical for tracking the rest phases.
Screen and control interface
One of the main arguments in the Honor Band dispute 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 5 The display is the quality. Honor's model is installed. AMOLED-diagonal 0.95 resolution 240×120 The pixel density is higher here, and the picture itself looks sharper and more saturated, especially when viewing notifications.
Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has a slightly smaller screen size of 1.1 inches, but with a resolution of 294×126 pixels. Despite the smaller diagonal, the brightness margin is higher here, which allows you to comfortably read information in direct sunlight. Both screens support the Always On Display function, although the implementation of this mode in Honor is more flexible.
The interface controls also have their own features: In the Honor Band 5, navigation is done through a touchpad and one physical button, which is common for many users. In the Xiaomi Mi Band 5, there is no physical button at all, all control is tied to swipes and taps, which sometimes leads to random clicks.
- 📱 Honor Band 5: Larger font, convenient for people with impaired vision.
- ☀️ Xiaomi Mi Band 5: Best readability in bright sun thanks to high margin of brightness.
- 🖱️ Interface: Having a physical button on Honor makes it easier to lock the screen.
💡
To save battery power, turn off the function of "Raising the wrist" and use tap screen activation, especially in bright sun.
Functional capabilities and sport
Both trackers are positioned as versatile sports assistants. Honor Band 5 offers 10 professional workout modes, including running, swimming and cycling. GPS-The module is absent in both devices, so to build a track you need to take a smartphone with you.
Xiaomi Mi Band 5 supports 11 sports modes and a new feature – tracking the activity of PAI (Personal Activity Intelligence), which measures your activity not in steps, but in points based on the heart rate, which allows you to more accurately plan your loads.
Water resistance is stated at 5 ATM for both devices, allowing swimming in the pool and showering. However, diving with them is not recommended due to the pressure difference. The accuracy of Xiaomi’s pulse measurement in the latest generation of sensors has become higher, especially during intensive interval training.
Comparison of sporting functions:
Honor Band 5: 10 modes, SpO2 (on some firmware), stress.
Xiaomi Mi Band 5: 11 modes, PAI, female cycle, REM-analysis of sleep.☑️ Pre-purchase check
Autonomy and charging process
The question of autonomy is often crucial when choosing which is better. Honor Band 5 is equipped with a 100 mAh battery. When used actively with constant monitoring of pulse and notifications, it lives about 7-9 days.
Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has a 125 mAh battery. Thanks to software optimization and a more energy-efficient screen, the device can last up to 14-20 days in normal mode. The difference of almost two weeks of battery life is a significant advantage of the model from Xiaomi.
However, the charging process is different: Honor has to remove the capsule from the strap and insert it into a special "comb", which can cause plastic ears to break during frequent cycles. Xiaomi has switched to magnetic charging, where the capsule is also removed, but the contact areas are more convenient and the risk of mechanical damage is lower.
⚠️ Warning: When removing the capsule from the strap, be extremely careful.Plastic in the cold becomes brittle and the Honor Band 5 mount may crack.
| Characteristics | Honor Band 5 | Xiaomi Mi Band 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Battery capacity | 100mAh | 125 mAh |
| Time to work. | 9 days | 20 days |
| Type of charging | Nest contacts | Magnetic |
| Charging time. | ~1.5 hours | ~2 hours |
Application and ecosystem
Both devices require a proprietary app installed on a smartphone. Honor Band 5 runs through Huawei Health, which is considered one of the most functional apps on the market, and features detailed sleep analysis, music management, phone search, and even camera control.
Xiaomi Mi Band 5 uses the Mi Fit app (now renamed Zepp Life).The interface here is more minimalistic, but sometimes suffers from synchronization problems on iOS. The functionality is similar, but the analytics in the Huawei app looks more visual and professional.
It is worth noting that the functionality of the bracelets can vary depending on the region. Chinese versions of the Honor Band 5 often have more features than global ones, but may not display Cyrillic notifications correctly. The global version of the Honor Band 5 has a software restriction on displaying emoji in notifications.
Notification problems on iOS
Final comparison and verdict
To sum up, the Honor Band 5 or Xiaomi Mi Band 5, both are excellent in their class, depending on your priorities. If you want a big screen, a physical button, and a detailed app, choose Honor.
If you’re more interested in autonomy, modern design, magnetic charging and slightly more accurate sensors, the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 will be the best choice, and Xiaomi also benefits from the availability of the original interchangeable straps, the range of which is huge.
At the time of the release, Xiaomi was more expensive, but now prices have leveled. In the current reality, the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 looks fresher and more technologically advanced device, while the Honor Band 5 remains a workhorse with a great screen.
- 🏆 Screen winner: Honor Band 5 (size and clarity).
- 🔋 Battery winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 5 (up to 20 days).
- 🛠 Winner for convenience: Xiaomi Mi Band 5 (magnetic charging).
💡
For most users, the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 will be a more rational choice thanks to modern charging and better autonomy, despite the smaller screen.